workman manufacturing in a car factory

The question of choosing a keyboard is acute for every active computer user. In stores, there is a huge range of gaming / working / budget devices that can be used for working, playing Blackjack online, or both. But all of them, with few exceptions, are made with the same technology – membrane.

Mechanical keyboards have been on the market for a long time, but so far for the average consumer, they are something too expensive and incomprehensible.

Here is a summary of the main differences between the mechanical and membrane keyboards to help you understand what we are talking about.

Technical Differences Between a Mechanical Keyboard and a Membrane Keyboard

A membrane keyboard is a three-layer rubber or silicone gasket placed on top of the electronic contacts. The entire surface of the pad is dotted with protruding “caps” on which the buttons with a plastic rod are attached. The key is actuated when the rod pushes the membrane down to the contacts, i.e. a full push is required.

In a mechanical keyboard, each key is equipped with an individual switching mechanism, which is triggered about halfway through the keystroke.

Differences Between a Membrane Keyboard and a Mechanical Keyboard

However, the terms “membrane”, “key stroke”, and “switch mechanism” do not help the average user make a choice. At most, you will be able to distinguish the different types of devices externally.

If you come to your computer once a day to watch a TV show or surf social networks, there’s no real difference between a mechanical and a membrane keyboard. It’s like buying a Ferrari to go to the country house once a week.

But if your job or hobby is closely related to working on the computer, buying a mechanical keyboard will be a better investment. There are several reasons for this:

  • Durability. A keyboard’s lifespan is measured not in years, but in the number of keystrokes. For a membrane keyboard, it is 5-10 million keystrokes, while for a mechanical keyboard it is 50 million.
  • Ability to match the device to your typing style. Press down hard, flutter with your fingers – every type of keyboard has its own type of switch.
  • Guaranteed key response. When you use a membrane keyboard, you’re forced to press keys all the way down, and some keystrokes may not work on a fast typing speed. The result is typos you may not even notice.
  • Health concerns. You’ll experience tunnel syndrome if you’re working with a computer all the time. A mechanical keyboard requires less effort to type, so your hands don’t get tired.

Now we can go back to the question in the title of the article. Which keyboard is better: a mechanical keyboard or a membrane keyboard? The answer is mechanical, if:

  • You spend most of your day at the computer (or rather, typing).
  • You’re not bothered by loud key clacking (many people, on the contrary, like it). Membrane keyboards sound much quieter than mechanical ones because the rubber and silicone cushion well.
  • You can afford it.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here